NCAA 12 vs. Madden 12

Danny Bateman

Danny Bateman

Donor
Which one are you guys looking forward to more?

I'd obviously venture to guess NCAA, as most of you are raring to go with DONU, and I myself usually enjoy NCAA more, but honestly from a totally objective standpoint, it sounds like all the upgrades to Franchise and Superstar in Madden outweigh the coaching carousel and addition of dreads in NCAA :)

But it's all a matter of opinion.

 
Madden will be a far superior product this year, which is really a shame, because the NCAA series (naturally) is more appealing to me. I wish 2K could still make football games :'( we'd be seeing some revolutionary products.

 
Madden games have the same problem every year that is impossible to fix - it's just not as interesting as college football to me. If there were ever a day dominated by college and nfl games, I'd watch the college games instead. If I had to choose between the NFL or college football going away forever, I'd choose the NFL.

That said, I'll probably get both and return the one I don't like.

 
I'm with Enhance on this-college football is WAY more exciting than NFL and because EA can't forcibly make me choose to like the NFL more, I'm going to continue to consider NCAA a better game than Madden. The only way I'll play Madden is if I get the game for free

 
Bye Bye Big XII said:
I'm with Enhance on this-college football is WAY more exciting than NFL and because EA can't forcibly make me choose to like the NFL more, I'm going to continue to consider NCAA a better game than Madden. The only way I'll play Madden is if I get the game for free
Click to expand...
Agree with bolded part.

 
Back
Top