Thanks_Tom RR
New member
So, 3-4 instead of 1-2?
I'm no expert but my vote would be 2-3 each year.So, 3-4 instead of 1-2?
Anderson got a med redshirt he will be here for two years.We graduated 7 (2 + 5) and pick up 8 (5 + 3) over the last two year. Only Anderson and Stakebaum will run out of eligibility this year. So, if my math is right, we only need one to break even. We could maybe add two LBs this year (if we get the right two), but I think there are other positions of need that should be focused on in this smaller class.What makes you think we only take one LB this class, just wondering.I think NU will only take one LB in this class, and I hope Yeargin is that guy. Great news that we are in his top 15. I would also like Jamarde Cobb, but he is primarily being recruited for RB (with an option to move to LB). Second on my list would be Jimmie Swain.
Yup. Recruiting needs to be based upon the needs of the future, not who is graduating. Graduating classes can get off balance for a lot of reasons (redshirts, transfers, injuries, etc). That doesn't mean we need to keep them imbalanced going forward. Overall class size and the occasional immediate need will cause some variance, but in general we should strive to take roughly the same number at most positions most years. For LB that should be roughly 2-3 per year.I'm no expert but my vote would be 2-3 each year.So, 3-4 instead of 1-2?
Right, like I said above we want him as a stand up DE/OLB like Thomas Brown/ Afalava or Gregory should be. Swain would be our true LB targetBTW... He is now 6'4" 225... and is projected at DE for many schools instead of LB. This may change things because we may want him at DE and Swain at LB.
I think Newby needs to put on a good 10lbs of muscle to have the endurance and strength at the next level though. He's only listed at 210lbs at this time. I'd like to see him playing at 220... just for durability's sake. I think we redshirt him.Right, like I said above we want him as a stand up DE/OLB like Thomas Brown/ Afalava or Gregory should be. Swain would be our true LB targetBTW... He is now 6'4" 225... and is projected at DE for many schools instead of LB. This may change things because we may want him at DE and Swain at LB.
I don't see Newby moving to safety he's going to be the real deal at LB
True. But I still think we can get away with 1-2 in this years class. We need to focus a lot of energy on DB's with how many we have leaving over the next couple of years. We have a lack of young guys at the CB/NB spots. Next year I think we take 3 LBers again.If nobody ever got hurt, transferred or just plain didn't pan out, I'd agree with you guys. However, in real life, less than half of kids work out for whatever reason, and you had better plan for that by continually recruiting balanced classes at all positions.
Yeah I think the hardly taking any corners for a few years is a huge hurt for us that we are going to endure over the next few years. One year it's okay. But two or more is problematic. I'm real nervous about them bringing in all these guys this year who are going to have to step it up and play next year and the year after without much experience.I'm OK with two and we'd likely survive fine with just one. I'm just leery of leaving holes in a long term depth chart, like we did by hardly taking any corners for a few years.
I understand what you saying but I'm just quoting coach Els here, he said were only taking one, and it would be hard to get a couple quality guys with our depth chart anyway. I'd be good with two, but I think we need 5 DBs this cycle as well.If nobody ever got hurt, transferred or just plain didn't pan out, I'd agree with you guys. However, in real life, less than half of kids work out for whatever reason, and you had better plan for that by continually recruiting balanced classes at all positions.