Should Mike Riley bench Tommy Armstrong?

RADAR said:
Rike Miley said:
TA is the only reason we are not 1-4 right now and the only reason why we didn't get blown out by Miami and you want him benched? That's comical
Click to expand...
Tommy is the main reason we have lost 3 games. Don't make me go into it again. Coaching gaffs no doubt, but Tommy can really muck it up sometimes.
Click to expand...
2366612-2529919625-laugh.gif


 
Hayseed said:
No, he's the best we have. Maybe Darlington is a better passer but he'd be risking his life with the number of concussions he's had.

The problem is the coaching....end of story.
Click to expand...
Yep. When a team's starting QB loses faith in his coaches by week 5 and starts to call his own plays...well..."Houston, we have a problem."

 
Last edited by a moderator:
MoneyBall said:
Yep. When a team's starting QB loses faith in his coaches by week 5 and starts to call his own plays...well..."Houston, we have a problem."
Click to expand...
wtf are you even saying? I've never used the 'ignore' function on this forum, but you're probably a good candidate.

You basically made up your point out of something that isn't there.

 
You are likely making way to much out of a simple mistaken in the verbage or something like that. Most likely the play was a 51 QB roll out right - no pass option and he simply caught it all but the 'no' in there. then Tommy speaks the play into the huddle with the pass option in instead of out. As a result, the players ran the play wrong. Probably very similar in many or nearly all ways except that it is designed for Tommy to run laterally to burn some extra clock and maybe get lucky and find a hole to cut up and get the first down.

Safer than a hand off arguably and yet with his running ability, a chance for a first down or more even. Nobody's fault as such - simply a failure in the communication process or Tommy forgot the play or as I say he heard it wrong. It can happen easily I am sure. Why don't we all give all involved the benefit of the doubt rather than convicting them or some of them to some capital offense and the sentence is banishment forever. That is simply nuts!

 
I say yes, and Fyfe would be my top choice. TA is too inconsistent in the passing game, against a conference full of teams that "know" defense.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
84HuskerLaw said:
You are likely making way to much out of a simple mistaken in the verbage or something like that. Most likely the play was a 51 QB roll out right - no pass option and he simply caught it all but the 'no' in there. then Tommy speaks the play into the huddle with the pass option in instead of out. As a result, the players ran the play wrong. Probably very similar in many or nearly all ways except that it is designed for Tommy to run laterally to burn some extra clock and maybe get lucky and find a hole to cut up and get the first down.

Safer than a hand off arguably and yet with his running ability, a chance for a first down or more even. Nobody's fault as such - simply a failure in the communication process or Tommy forgot the play or as I say he heard it wrong. It can happen easily I am sure. Why don't we all give all involved the benefit of the doubt rather than convicting them or some of them to some capital offense and the sentence is banishment forever. That is simply nuts!
Click to expand...
That's a reasonable explanation. Or maybe he knew he wasn't supposed to pass it, but he improvised. He saw that he could avoid a loss of yardage (taking us out of what he thought was FG range), and could possibly win the game, by completing a three-yard pass to Ozigbo. Remember, if we get the first down we win, at that point. In that split second--throw it, or don't throw it--neither Tommy nor anyone else could have predicted that Illinois would march down the field in 50 seconds and score a go ahead touchdown. The consequences of that third down pass look much worse in retrospect than they did in that split second.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Plaza23 said:
Talent reasons alone - I think there's an argument to bench him because his accuracy is bad, his decision making is questionable, and he really looks like a RB trying to play QB in a passing offense - and that has never worked for any team.
Click to expand...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Who on here was knows for a fact that Tommy called the right play that the coaches signaled? Who on here knows that for sure? I am not questioning Tommy's ability, but rather his leadership ability. Jeff George was as talented as any QB to ever lace up cleats, but had no leadership, and teams got tired of playing with and for him. I question leadership. Brook Beringer was not a top tier option QB, but his leadership propelled the rest of the team to do their part, thus making him a hero. Something to be said for gathering the troops around you, and them believing you can get the job done.

All in all, right now the QB is one position. I see many spots on both sides of the ball that need some attention. Where do you start? Whose attention is grabbed first?

On a fair note for Tommy, when your best receiver is Westerkamp, your options become easy defensive game plans. DPE would and will make a difference if he sees the field. I am thinking he is the golden goose for Riley. Great excuse for lack of offense is to say your best threat on offense didn't see the field this year. Your game changing punt.kickoff returner was sidelined..........

 
Nebhawk said:
Who on here was knows for a fact that Tommy called the right play that the coaches signaled? Who on here knows that for sure? I am not questioning Tommy's ability, but rather his leadership ability. Jeff George was as talented as any QB to ever lace up cleats, but had no leadership, and teams got tired of playing with and for him. I question leadership. Brook Beringer was not a top tier option QB, but his leadership propelled the rest of the team to do their part, thus making him a hero. Something to be said for gathering the troops around you, and them believing you can get the job done.

All in all, right now the QB is one position. I see many spots on both sides of the ball that need some attention. Where do you start? Whose attention is grabbed first?

On a fair note for Tommy, when your best receiver is Westerkamp, your options become easy defensive game plans. DPE would and will make a difference if he sees the field. I am thinking he is the golden goose for Riley. Great excuse for lack of offense is to say your best threat on offense didn't see the field this year. Your game changing punt.kickoff returner was sidelined..........
Click to expand...
There are a lot of things you can question on Tommy Armstrong. Leadership is not one of them.

 
Why are we even discussing benching Tommy. Statistically this has easily been his best year I would think.

If Tommy is struggling to grasp the offense, if you believe that, what makes you think one of the back ups would come in and be a better starter????

This thread = dumb.

 
Back
Top