That's well said, too, bnilhome. I can understand anyone who's given up hopes of Tommy turning it around. Heck, I'm pretty "well, let's wait-and-see" about this myself -- but he's so eminently likable it's hard for me not to get swept back into cheerleader mode.
If he's unable to live up to it next year, it might mean a bad season, but there'll be other things to be excited about. Such as the potential blossoming of a freshman QB talent.
I guess we all see things a different way. I am a manager at the company I work for, and am accountable for 25 direct reports. I've been in situations where somebody has wanted to be on a special assignment even though it was not a good fit for their skillset, and I have given them that opportunity, and it did not work out. No matter how much they asked to be given another chance and they would change, I've had to make the tough call that it's not the right fit for their skillset. If I had known they really didn't try that hard when given that assignment, I would be livid that they wasted an entire year and impacted all of those around them in the process.
As for the prospect of another bad season, I don't think NU fans are up for that, and I don't think Riley and his staff can afford it. If we have another 5-7 or 6-6 season, Riley should be given the boot. The only reason that TA should start next year is if Riley chooses to do something he's never done in 30 years of coaching...run an option QB offense. That plays to TA's skillset better than the other QBs. If Riley wants to advance his pro-style passing attack which we saw this past season, TA is not the right fit (as many have pointed out...square peg in round hole theory). The worst thing that can happen in 2016 is that Riley elects to keep his pro-style offense and tries to continue fitting the square peg (TA) in the round hole.