I'm not a fan of our legal system, too many criminals get off free when they are guilty and too many who are innocent get locked up.
I am a fan of justice and natural law.
Ignoring everything outside of Maurice's control (being in the video, making the video, etc...) and only focusing on Maurice's actions alone (keeping the video, sending it to the girl) is more than enough in my court of what is right and what is wrong with this world for a conviction. I don't care how good or great a football player you are, you simply do not do that as a decent Human being and that is certainly not the case with him as he has proven with his actions. I don't care about the legality of it all, he is guilty in my book and should be immediately expelled from the school.