Not sure what you mean by “freedom” but I hope you are not in some way dismissing freedom (basic civil / human rights) like all that stuff in the Declaration of Independence and Constitution, especially that little section called the Bill of Rights.
There can be a tendency for people to be willing to give up freedom in exchange for security. This is short-sighted and often in the long term ends up with the loss of both.
Even temporary infringements are unconstitutional and must be protected. The shutdown orders are unprecedented, extreme, very arbitrary and capricious. Based on the “police powers” mostly, at most these actions should be minimized (scope, time, etc). After months and months and very little real evidence as to efficacy as to purpose and application, the tolerance of the people to be subjected to all of this amazes me. On one hand, it shows the strong community spirit of cooperation with what has been presented as a national health emergency (it is). On the other hand, it troubles me greatly to see the submissive and almost ignorant reaction by so many to the deprivation of life, liberty and property and inalienable rights. These are the essence of freedom that is America at its core.
The shutdown orders were, in fact, delayed, inconsistent, and often un-enforced, but they were ultimately effective. Any interpretation of the data shows a clear correlation between quarantine mandates and flattening the curve, just as it shows a correlation between the recent loosening of restrictions and the resurgence of the virus. You can't blame the scientists for knowing this, nor the many levels of government that have to make difficult public health decisions. Not to mention private public health decisions, like playing sports.
And let's face it, the shutdown probably couldn't have happened if Americans didn't see dead bodies being stacked like cordwood in New York, Italy, Spain, and New Orleans. Left to our own "freedoms" and devices, COVID is definitely capable of a nightmare scenario. When thousands are dying or in ICU and healthcare is overwhelmed, the economy tanks, too. Countries whose governments handled this much better than the U.S. will emerge to do free enterprise business and play sports sooner than we will.
I think we forget this is going on in virtually every country in the world. The temptation is to make this an American ideological battle, but governments as diverse as Japan, France, Iran, India, South Korea, Belgium, Germany, etc, all recognized the coronavirus as an unprecedented threat and virtually every country enacted governmental restrictions -- some far more strict than the U.S. They did not doubt the science then, and nothing has happened to suggest the scientists were inherently wrong --- merely that there's still a lot to learn.
There's a ton of leeway in how each of us assesses our risk factor, and I don't know anyone who doesn't want to get their freedoms back and the economy on track. People who stay home as much as possible and wear masks everywhere in public aren't being submissive to the government, they're listening to the experts and exercising their own abundance of caution. People who pointedly refuse to wear masks in public and refuse to social distance on principle aren't fighting for personal freedom, they're just being dicks. Most of us are somewhere in between.
If we have to choose between the America that sacrifices together for the common good, or the America that lets public health be determined by our fearless individualists, I'm probably going to go with the former.