Here is one concern I have in all of this: We are in our current situation (bad QB play) primarily because FHCSF had 'his' QB picked before he got here and had him pegged as the starter from day one. As a result, we had a 4 year starter and the QB room was never developed beyond # 1. Perhaps we already see some of that developing now - even before DR has signed with DK looking at MSU. This is the downside of picking the 'can't miss' recruit. With NIL, that can't miss recruit could also become ex-can't miss if he transfers to greener pastures in 2-3 years. That is the Debbie downer side of this.
The ideal is to bring in that good 4-5 star QB who has one year left to play next year while preparing both DK and DR to compete in year 2. I think that is what Rhule is trying to do. But if both DR and that 5 star 1 year QB both insist on being the starter for next year - then we are back in the same situation as you have to go wt DR for the long term potential at that point and hope his adjustment to college ball is quick.