How one extra second changed the college football season
By Steve Wieberg, USA TODAY
Did they know?As they peered at the images on their TV screen at the end of the Big 12 Conference championship game two weekends ago, could replay officials have understood the enormity of the call they were about to make? Phone down a ruling that the game had ended with an incomplete Texas pass, and an entire college football season would lurch one way. Restore time — even a single second — and it would turn another.
They restored the second.
The field was cleared, Big 12 North champion Nebraska called time out to extend the delay and try to freeze Texas kicker Hunter Lawrence, and the Longhorns' senior coolly curled a 46-yard field goal inside the left upright to give them a 13-12 victory.
The repercussions were vast, shaping the makeup and tenor of the national championship race and major bowl picture, factoring into voting for the Heisman Trophy and perhaps altering the immediate future of one of the sport's signature programs.
Mack Brown, for one, couldn't appreciate the what-ifs until he was airborne to New York and the Heisman Trophy ceremony almost a week later. "I was flying up with one of our boosters, one of my best friends," Texas' coach says. "He's kind of propped back in his seat on the plane, and he hit me with, 'You understand that beween 40,000 and 60,000 Texas fans were sitting there with tickets in their hands — plane tickets, room reservations, some of them saved up for a year — and they wouldn't have been very happy if you hadn't won the game.
"Very honestly, coaches are working. You can't possibly think of all the negative things that could happen. … So none of that stuff hit me."Take away that pivotal second, and …
•Texas, with a loss, tumbles out of the national title picture. Cincinnati most likely steps in (barring rethinking by voters in the two polls that fold into the Bowl Championship Series rankings). The Bearcats not only move past newly beaten Florida and Texas but also past TCU, jumping from No. 5 to No. 2 the final BCS rankings to claim the berth opposite Alabama in the Jan. 7 title game in Pasadena, Calif.
•That sets off an uproar that, even by BCS standards, is Richter-scale worthy. Mountain West champion TCU looked poised to strike a major blow against the longtime subordination of college football's five middle- and lower-echelon conferences — the Mountain West, Western Athletic, Conference USA, Mid-American and Sun Belt — giving one of their own a shot at winning it all. Then, computers pulled the rug.
Note what actually happened Dec. 6.
TCU entered the previous weekend atop Big East champion Cincinnati in the USA TODAY coaches' and Harris Interactive polls, and those voters kept the Horned Frogs a spot ahead. But the BCS also folds six computer rankings into its composite standings, and four of them gave Cincinnati a bump in the wake of the Bearcats' 45-44 win vs. Pittsburgh. Two more dropped idle TCU a spot. That allowed Cincinnati to edge the Frogs by a .0042 of a point in the final overall standings.
•Big 12 champion Nebraska is now headed for the Tostitos Fiesta Bowl and Texas becomes an at-large BCS entry, bumping … whom?
Three other conference champions are automatically slotted into affiliated bowls: Ohio State and Oregon into the Rose, Georgia Tech into the FedEx Orange. Now comes a draft of TCU and three at-large BCS entries. The Allstate Sugar Bowl, picking first, likely takes Florida. The Orange, picking second, is a good bet to leap at Texas or perhaps Iowa, a longtime bowls favorite because of the legions of fans it brings. The Fiesta, picking third, goes with unbeaten TCU.
That leaves one BCS slot, in the Sugar, and two candidates for selection in Boise State and the Texas-Iowa leftover. If the pick here is anything but 13-0 Boise, the BCS' many critics go doubly ballistic. The five non-marquee conferences are shorted again.
•The ground, meanwhile, has shifted beneath Cincinnati's Brian Kelly and Notre Dame, which is eying him as its next coach. Can Kelly bail on the Bearcats, or announce a pending move, a month before they play for their first national championship? Can Notre Dame hold off on a hire — on putting together a staff and making a proper run at recruits — until almost mid-January? The guess is no and no.
"I might not be here at Notre Dame," Kelly told a Chicago radio station earlier this week, "because we don't know if they would have waited. … I was going to play in the national championship game."
Notre Dame probably looks elsewhere, maybe to Connecticut's Randy Edsall.
•Allowing the clock to run down and ultimately out while taking his final snap and throwing the final incompletion against Nebraska leaves a stain on Texas quarterback Colt McCoy's otherwise splendid four-year career. By the eve of the game, fewer than 10% of the Heisman Trophy's 926 voters had cast their ballots. Enough are soured that last year's runner-up doesn't get a return trip to New York as a 2009 finalist.
Conversely, a surge of support for Nebraska tackle Ndamukong Suh is even greater in the wake of his sizable contribution — 4½ sacks and seven overall tackles for losses — to the upset of the season over McCoy and the Longhorns. He moves from fourth in the balloting into the top three, maybe higher.
•Texas has drawn up a stunning $2 million annual raise for Brown that will make him college football's first $5 million man. Regents are to meet days after the game to rubber-stamp it. But does the loss, and especially the clock mismanagement at the end, at least delay the timing?
Brown recalls the deep disappointment of 2008, when a dramatic, early-November loss at Texas Tech cost Texas a shot at the Big 12 and BCS titles. Tech's Graham Harrell and Michael Crabtree hooked up on a game-turning, 28-yard touchdown pass with, ironically, a single second remaining. "The sad thing about this would have been that the juniors who became seniors had a similar ending to last year when they really deserved more," Brown says.
"It would have been a crushing blow for Texas."