Even if he does stay healthy, I just get the feeling he doesn't have what it takes in the big games. And last I checked, we have 6 or 7 big games this season.
If I had to guess, I'd say we'll need to depend on Carnes for at least a couple games this year. Don't get me wrong b/c I love Carnes and think he is the future, but we all know how bumpy things can get with someone who has minimal big game PT.
So... you have no confidence in a guy who struggled as an injured Freshman playing behind an injured O Line with an OC who was lost half the time, but you do have confidence in Carnes who has never taken a D1A snap?
This makes no sense to me.
Let me clarify. I think we'll have to depend on Carnes because I don't think there's any way Martinez gets through the season without needing to sit out because of injury. I said things will probably be bumpy with Carnes this year, especially if we have to depend on him WHEN Martinez goes down. So what part of "bumpy" did you take as "confidence in Carnes"?
Also, I should add that I do have some confidence in Martinez, at least enough to trust he'll help us destroy non-conf teams.
It's those big conference games when his confidence and poise will be tested most that I worry.