Why would Israel attack Iran?

Cactusboy said:
walksalone said:
Cactusboy said:
walksalone said:
Answer the question, or continue perpetuating the fact that the arguements posed are all bullsh*t
Click to expand...
page 4, post 173 covers this. if that's not good enough bring it up in the shed
Click to expand...
not answering the question, but dancing around it...

you're not on national TV running for public office, just answer the question
Click to expand...

you have to be more specific. who is right in WHAT situation? Who is right on what if Israel should build settlements? Hamas is right on that. I'm not going to keep guessing what specific things you want to know who is right on, so I'll leave it up to you to give specific examples. Will you do that..or will you dance around?
Click to expand...
dancing around the questions again...

walksalone said:
not what I was asking, and most would know what I'm getting at, so I'll rephrase...

Who is right in this situation, Israel or Hamas?
Click to expand...
 
I'm calling you on your BS question. Neither has done NO wrong. You are proposing a loaded question which is a BS tactic used by a weak debater. Can you even comprehend what a loaded question is? The BS is you acting like your clever by asking it over and over.

Should we go over what a loaded question is in more depth and see why it's such a BS tactic of a weak debater?

Keep up w/ this exchange...it's reflecting greatly on you. :)

 
Cactusboy said:
I'm calling you on your BS question. Neither has done NO wrong. You are proposing a loaded question which is a BS tactic used by a weak debater. Can you even comprehend what a loaded question is? The BS is you acting like your clever by asking it over and over.

Should we go over what a loaded question is in more depth and see why it's such a BS tactic of a weak debater?

Keep up w/ this exchange...it's reflecting greatly on you. :)
Click to expand...
because you can't answer....

 
johnnyrodgers20 said:
knapplc said:
Cactusboy said:
Remember this whole exchange is about if and how often Hamas breaks ceasefires. They are the party/group in charge of Gaza.
Click to expand...
Now who's moving the goal posts? Nobody said this was ONLY about Hamas. It's about Israel and their occupation of territories, and the response of Palestinians. Hamas is only one group, and we're talking about them for the moment. All of Palestine is responding to Israel, though, and we're going to be dealing with the entirety of the situation, not just specific groups. Have to. Can't take it piecemeal, because it's not a situation of having truces with one group for all groups.
Click to expand...
Knapp I am going to give you some advice. We went round and round before on this subject. He will change and move the posts forever. He is right and you can't tell him a thing, the best you can do is just let him spout and throw up his little jabs and be done with it. He can't even say bombing a bus of innocent people is wrong without somehow tying it to the Israeli govt. and their policies that are the real cause of the killings. Just a little advice!! :D
Click to expand...

Ok, this is the first time I see anyone talking about bombing a bus. JR, where did I ever talk about bombing a bus...or even said anything about a bus?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Cactusboy said:
Ok, this is the first time I see anyone talking about bombing a bus. JR, where did I ever talk about bombing a bus...or even said anything about a bus?
Click to expand...
Bombing a bus with civilians in it is ALWAYS WRONG, as is flying a comercial plane into office buildings.

Let me repeat that... THAT.

It is just as wrong as when MeK, PJAK or the IDF kills Iranian civilians in similar manners.

Any American politician who supports funding MeK to continue operations inside Iran is no better tha Usama bin Laden.

Enemy or not... bombing a bus with civilians in it is ALWAYS WRONG.

 
Sub-Husker said:
Cactusboy said:
Ok, this is the first time I see anyone talking about bombing a bus. JR, where did I ever talk about bombing a bus...or even said anything about a bus?
Click to expand...
Bombing a bus with civilians in it is ALWAYS WRONG, as is flying a comercial plane into office buildings.

Let me repeat that... THAT.

It is just as wrong as when MeK, PJAK or the IDF kills Iranian civilians in similar manners.

Any American politician who supports funding MeK to continue operations inside Iran is no better tha Usama bin Laden.

Enemy or not... bombing a bus with civilians in it is ALWAYS WRONG.
Click to expand...

Goes w/out say. Somehow JR thinks I said/think bombing a bus is ok even though many times I've condemned Hammas or any arab for when they do terrorism.

Man this place has turned into a cesspool...

 
Cactusboy said:
Man this place has turned into a cesspool...
Click to expand...
carlfense said:
Funny how that happened after your previous cesspool was shut down.
Click to expand...
It is good to have people here with diverse opinions, who can lay out a position and defend it without Romneying when the audience changes or it gets uncomfortable.

While the dig on HuskerPedia was funny, it died because of a fight over advertising revenue, and had not become a cesspool until its final days when participants from the new owner's board showed up en masse to trash the place. Cactusboy was the only moderator who stayed around during that time and tried to maintain order. The work he did as a moderator during that time was exemplorary.

While your comment was humorous and well timed, it also happens to be very inaccurate.

 
Back
Top