Swifty and Peterson dropped a few in their day. Held to the same standards we have built up now (in reaction to some drop heavy performances at times, notably in that Texas game, I guess, and Niles Paul's varying absurd errors), they would be ridiculed similarly.
Lacking statistics for drops per throw, I have to say I completely disagree with you. I don't think our standards are any higher now than they were. As a team we seem to be dropping way more catchable throws than before. Without statistics I suppose this is just a matter of opinion, though. The dropsies are not an isolated incident like the Texas game. Kinnie basically inherited Niles Paul's problem. Overall we're not horrible the past few years if you exclude Kinnie & Paul. Maybe now that Kinnie is gone it will go better, but I thought the same thing would happen when Paul was gone.
Yeah, it's hard to say because it's subjective in the end. I remember at least one clear drop from Swift - along with the surprise that came with it - and I believe "The Drive" vs A&M saw a couple from Peterson. I don't think we disagree as much as you think, though.
Paul/Kinnie had issues (Kinnie at least at the start of the year). That I think, is clear, and the flak they caught, they deserved. I am saying
as a result of their issues, we're getting very trigger-happy with the "Man! this WR needs to get hands" line as applied towards our other receivers. I have a screenshot I posted here at one point of a play for which Bell was panned, where he had to
lay out just to be able to make contact with an errant ball.
Swift/Peterson benefited from unusual rapport with their QB, and enough targets that they could easily wipe the memory of the occasional drop here and there, which anybody has, with more completions. But the way some people talk, those guys had the best hands ever while our current QB is still getting hosed by a slacking group of WRs. I don't believe this is the case. Taylor's inconsistent throwing is at least as much at fault, so it's extra good that he is ironing out that part of his game.