12-Team Playoff On the Way; 14-Team to Follow

Gorillahawk said:
For the most part I disagree with this. A playoff system allows teams to schedule tougher OOC opponents, because a loss doesn't eliminate them from NC contention. Why would an Ohio State, Georgia, or anyone else want to schedule a game against a like opponent early in the season if it means a loss could potentially eliminate you from any chance to play for the NC? Scheduling a top tier team allows you to get better, win or lose. I hate how the SEC teams always schedule a FCS or bottom G5 team at the end of the season. A close loss to an undefeated or 1 loss Ohio State looks a lot better than a win of the little sisters of the poor university. 

I like the playoff, imagine what a playoff would have meant for the 96 huskers, or any other Nebraska team of the pass that was arguably the best team in the country who was screwed because they lost to an equally good OU team in a rivalry game? How many times have we seen a team that was clearly one of the top teams in CFB stumble and a lesser team get in and get blown out? A playoff has a better chance of letting the true best team rise to the top imo.
Click to expand...


You're making the entertainment argument, which I can't argue with. Its logically sound, and the entertainment factor is what drives the debates. I would've like the playoff for the '99 Huskers. The '96 team might have won a playoff, but they weren't consistently the best team that season.

 
Moiraine said:
It's possible it's less exciting for a team that's currently undefeated, because they know they can mess up.
Click to expand...


That has been an argument for awhile. But I'd like someone to actually point out which undefeated (or whatever) team just mailed in a game because they knew they were in the playoff.

 
I have always thought once we went to this 12 team format there will be multiple teams in the playoff who don't really belong in a NC title talk.  Here we are.  We wanted more teams, many teams probably shouldn't be there.  The only thing that is important at the end of the day, is that the best team is included.  I beleive they are there.  Only a few of these teams have a real chance.

 
Crusader Husker said:
I have always thought once we went to this 12 team format there will be multiple teams in the playoff who don't really belong in a NC title talk.  Here we are.  We wanted more teams, many teams probably shouldn't be there.  The only thing that is important at the end of the day, is that the best team is included.  I beleive they are there.  Only a few of these teams have a real chance.
Click to expand...


Eh, I don't think there's anyone so dominant that they are that much better than even the bottom teams in the playoff.  There isn't as much gap as people like to believe.  It's all about who plays well, stays healthy and gets a couple of breaks.

Oregon only beat Idaho by 10 and Wisconsin by 3

Ohio State only beat Nebraska (!) by 4

Texas only beat Vanderbilt by 3 and Arkansas by 10

Penn State only beat Bowling Green by 7, USC by 3 and Minnesota by 1

Notre Dame lost to Northern Illinois

Miami needed a replay miracle to beat Virginia Tech, only beat Cal by 1 and lost to Georgia Tech

Georgia only beat Kentucky by 1 and Mississippi State by 10

Tennessee lost to Arkansas

All those teams would be the higher seed if the playoffs started now.

 
Crusader Husker said:
I have always thought once we went to this 12 team format there will be multiple teams in the playoff who don't really belong in a NC title talk.  Here we are.  We wanted more teams, many teams probably shouldn't be there.  The only thing that is important at the end of the day, is that the best team is included.  I beleive they are there.  Only a few of these teams have a real chance.
Click to expand...
That's the beauty of a playoff.  Get in and see what happens.  Any top 15 team can beat any team once, happens all the time. Play the games on the field, instead of just talking who we think belongs and who doesn't. 

 
Yes they might be in the playoff guaranteed if they are undefeated - but lose this week and then the conference championship game and you lose both a bye and homefield for the first round so every game is important.  If someone were 100% confident they could win the CCG then maybe they would phone it in this week but I don't see anyone in that position.  Every team locked into their CCG game going into the final week has bad consequences facing them if they lose this week and then don't win the CCG.

 
I don't like the playoff system already, but that's me.  Tired of the SEC and ESPN side of things already.

Don't see where this is actually any better for college football.  Sure it gains more attention and potential for home games for a few schools, but overall, it going to be more about politics than who we actually think is deserving.  Eye test this season would tell me that there is no dominant team or conference in my opinion.  I see about 30 teams that on any given Saturday could beat any team they play based on a one game scenario.    

 
Nebhawk said:
I don't like the playoff system already, but that's me.  Tired of the SEC and ESPN side of things already.

Don't see where this is actually any better for college football.  Sure it gains more attention and potential for home games for a few schools, but overall, it going to be more about politics than who we actually think is deserving.  Eye test this season would tell me that there is no dominant team or conference in my opinion.  I see about 30 teams that on any given Saturday could beat any team they play based on a one game scenario.    
Click to expand...
I mean that’s exactly why an expanded playoff is good for the sport. I don’t disagree with the SEC slant but sticking to a 4 team playoff would just mean SEC gets half the field every year and then we’re arguing and politicking to justify the other 2 spots.

there are no dominant teams this year- I see that more of a result of NIL and the portal.  It’s increasingly harder for the top teams to just hoard 5 stars across the depth chart when players can make more money and exposure playing elsewhere.  It’s also worth mentioning that the greatest coach in the history of college football is finally gone and the coach won the natty is also gone.  Georgia the one program that can somewhat claim powerhouse at the moment, Oregon is trying- but the sport is incredibly open which is a great thing.

as it pertains to us, the 12 team playoff, and if it expands further, is a blessing for our program.  Today f#&%ing sucked for sure, to the point where I’m seriously rethinking bowl trip plans, but a mediocre special teams and a competent offense would’ve had us a 9-3 program this year and fringe playoff consideration.  
 

unless we strike absolutely gold with the transfer portal, we will never be a 11-1/ 12-0 program again and need to play for that 6-15 range and make a run. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Nebhawk said:
Eye test this season would tell me that there is no dominant team or conference in my opinion.  I see about 30 teams that on any given Saturday could beat any team they play based on a one game scenario.    
Click to expand...
If you don't think this is better for college football, with an expanded playoff, I don't know what to tell you.

 
Not sure there are 12 teams deserving of the playoff this year, but I guess you have to fill the field.

Hell, not sure there are 4 teams deserving this year.

 
Back
Top