No matter what you do, we are going to have some really good guys on the bench. It's a good problem to have, but it's frustrating.
We have 8 spots to look at for our starting lineup (3 OF + 4 INF + 1 DH; i'm going to exclude C), and I listed 11 guys. Which means 3 of them can't start in any given game. Who should those 3 be? Here's how our players are doing so far (AVG/OBP/SLG)
Outfielders
Pritchard .447/.500/.474
Kiser .214/.421/.405
Sanguinetti .283/.345/.472
Darby .294/.375/.382
Infielders
Farmer .289/.341/.395
Peters .317/.383/.415
Stock .463/.488/.683
Kelly .429/.467/.571*
Other
Christensen .424/.477/.644
Scheffert .343/.378/.429
Kalkowski .273/.294/.425
*Limited sample size
So, who are some obvious chioces that need to be playing? Christensen, Stock, Pritchard. Right now, they have incredible lines.
Who is the next line of players that need to be in the game? Sheffert, Peters, Kiser, Sanguinetti. These guys are getting on base, which is they key to winning games. Look at a guy like Kiser, he may not have the best AVG but his OBP is very good. When he can start hitting the ball a little better he will definitely be in the "needs to play" category.
Where does that leave us? So far I have listed 3 OF, 2 INF, and 2 others. Sheffert and Christensen can both go back and forth between INF and OF, so it can become a bit of a puzzle. Who's the next guy we want in the game? And where do we put him? Here's a few ideas:
1B: Stock
2B: Peters
3B: Scheffert/Farmer
SS: Christensen
LF: Pritchard
CF: Sanguinetti
RF: Kiser
DH: Kalkowski/Farmer/Sheffert
With something like this, ONE of Kalkowski, Sheffert, Farmer would have to sit out. Or, we could switch things around a bit more and get:
1B: Stock
2B: Peters
3B: Scheffert
SS: Farmer
LF: Kiser
CF: Sanguinetti
RF: Christensen
DH: Pritchard
This leaves Kash out. Kash hasn't been hitting the ball too well this year, but he should be one of the better players on the team when he comes around. Hopefully Darin can see who has the hot hand and get them in the game, but right now to me it seems like we defintely need to see MORE Pritchard and Stock. If Kelly can continue to post those numbers, that just adds another element to the discussion.
Like I said, it's a good problem to have. Hopefully we can find a good mix between playing time for everyone and rewarding those who are hot. If only the pitching had this much depth!