Scarlet Overkill
New member
I said one player succeeding has nothing to do with another succeeding.
And this thread illustrates the source problem with recruiting: nobody seems to be allowed to express any doubt about a players ability.
One-third to half of every recruiting class doesn't pan out. That's just the nature of recruiting. Everybody seems to think that every player we sign will be an all-american or at least very good and that simply is not statistical reality.
You're allowed to have doubts, and you're right that so many don't pan out. But, some do, and you get none of those if you take no chances. Anyway, I personally value your opinions, but in this one case, i just happen to disagree.
Carry on.