knapplc
Active member
I started a contest like this several years ago and never finished it, for some reason. It's high time we fix that problem. We'll spend the next few weeks sorting out the rankings and then voting for the greatest of all time.
As I dust off the old stuff I'd compiled to run this thing way back in 2007, I found this list, all seeded and ready to go. Everyone take a look at this thing and tell me where it's right and wrong, and if anyone who played in the past five years needs to be added.
Updated list
R Player POS
1 Barry Sanders RB
2 Archie Griffin RB
3 Bo Jackson RB
4 Jim Thorpe RB
5 Red Grange RB
6 Doak Walker RB
7 Jim Brown RB
8 OJ Simpson RB
9 Earl Campbell RB
10 Tommie Frazier QB
11 Gale Sayers RB
12 Billy Sims RB
13 Vince Young QB
14 Herschel Walker RB
15 Eric Dickerson RB
16 Jamelle Holieway QB
17 Mike Rozier RB
18 Will Shields OL
19 Orlando Pace OL
20 Rickey Williams RB
21 Eric Crouch QB
22 Roger Staubach QB
23 Sammy Baugh QB
24 Dave Rimington OL
25 Bronko Nagurski DL
26 Tony Dorsett RB
27 Marcus Allen RB
28 Dan Marino QB
29 Ron Dayne RB
30 Charlie Ward QB
31 Tom Harmon RB
32 Lawrence Taylor LB
33 Brian Bosworth LB
34 George Gipp RB
35 Johnny Rodgers WR
36 Ndamukong Suh DL
37 Reggie Bush RB
38 Steve Emtman DL
39 d!(k Butkus LB
40 Warren Sapp DL
41 Calvin Johnson WR
42 Larry Fitzgerald WR
43 Troy Davis WR
44 John Elway QB
45 Hugh Green DL
46 Rashaan Salaam RB
47 Rich Glover DL
48 Mike Singletary LB
49 Mike Ditka LB
50 Charles Woodsen CB
51 Bernie Kosar QB
52 Tim Tebow QB
53 Larry Czonka RB
54 James Street QB
55 John Hannah OL
56 Charley Trippi RB
57 Alex Karras DL
58 Bob Brown OL
59 Keyshawn Johnson WR
60 Dat Nguyen LB
61 Carl Eller DL
62 Dan Hampton DL
63 Sterling Sharpe TE
64 Charles Rogers WR
As I dust off the old stuff I'd compiled to run this thing way back in 2007, I found this list, all seeded and ready to go. Everyone take a look at this thing and tell me where it's right and wrong, and if anyone who played in the past five years needs to be added.
Updated list
R Player POS
1 Barry Sanders RB
2 Archie Griffin RB
3 Bo Jackson RB
4 Jim Thorpe RB
5 Red Grange RB
6 Doak Walker RB
7 Jim Brown RB
8 OJ Simpson RB
9 Earl Campbell RB
10 Tommie Frazier QB
11 Gale Sayers RB
12 Billy Sims RB
13 Vince Young QB
14 Herschel Walker RB
15 Eric Dickerson RB
16 Jamelle Holieway QB
17 Mike Rozier RB
18 Will Shields OL
19 Orlando Pace OL
20 Rickey Williams RB
21 Eric Crouch QB
22 Roger Staubach QB
23 Sammy Baugh QB
24 Dave Rimington OL
25 Bronko Nagurski DL
26 Tony Dorsett RB
27 Marcus Allen RB
28 Dan Marino QB
29 Ron Dayne RB
30 Charlie Ward QB
31 Tom Harmon RB
32 Lawrence Taylor LB
33 Brian Bosworth LB
34 George Gipp RB
35 Johnny Rodgers WR
36 Ndamukong Suh DL
37 Reggie Bush RB
38 Steve Emtman DL
39 d!(k Butkus LB
40 Warren Sapp DL
41 Calvin Johnson WR
42 Larry Fitzgerald WR
43 Troy Davis WR
44 John Elway QB
45 Hugh Green DL
46 Rashaan Salaam RB
47 Rich Glover DL
48 Mike Singletary LB
49 Mike Ditka LB
50 Charles Woodsen CB
51 Bernie Kosar QB
52 Tim Tebow QB
53 Larry Czonka RB
54 James Street QB
55 John Hannah OL
56 Charley Trippi RB
57 Alex Karras DL
58 Bob Brown OL
59 Keyshawn Johnson WR
60 Dat Nguyen LB
61 Carl Eller DL
62 Dan Hampton DL
63 Sterling Sharpe TE
64 Charles Rogers WR
Last edited by a moderator:
