Madden 12

Blaze1up said:
Agree, I'm college thru and thru but when it comes to video game football I'm all about the best and in this case it's obvious.
Click to expand...

It's really frustrating that EA doesn't just use the same model for NCAA and Madden (same game just with college vs. NFL teams, maybe some minor gameplay tweaks). Like you said, it's obvious that Madden is superior and that is the case every year. I doubt fans of either series would complain if they were extremely similar. EA needs to bring NCAA up to Madden's level.

 
Husker Richard said:
Blaze1up said:
Agree, I'm college thru and thru but when it comes to video game football I'm all about the best and in this case it's obvious.
Click to expand...

It's really frustrating that EA doesn't just use the same model for NCAA and Madden (same game just with college vs. NFL teams, maybe some minor gameplay tweaks). Like you said, it's obvious that Madden is superior and that is the case every year. I doubt fans of either series would complain if they were extremely similar. EA needs to bring NCAA up to Madden's level.
Click to expand...

Last year NCAA was on a higher level, as it also was from '07-'09 (which isn't saying much).

 
Got it, but haven't played it yet... reviews aren't the best I'll say that. gamespot gave it a 7.5 i believe and most of the time their ratings fit my tastes.

 
Landlord of Memorial Stadium said:
Husker Richard said:
Blaze1up said:
Agree, I'm college thru and thru but when it comes to video game football I'm all about the best and in this case it's obvious.
Click to expand...

It's really frustrating that EA doesn't just use the same model for NCAA and Madden (same game just with college vs. NFL teams, maybe some minor gameplay tweaks). Like you said, it's obvious that Madden is superior and that is the case every year. I doubt fans of either series would complain if they were extremely similar. EA needs to bring NCAA up to Madden's level.
Click to expand...

Last year NCAA was on a higher level, as it also was from '07-'09 (which isn't saying much).
Click to expand...

I disagree. Madden has always had better graphics, more realistic animations, better presentation, players play like their real-life counterparts, etc., etc.

 
Blaze1up

Blaze1up

New member
Once again Madden is boss, love the demo. Drops Aug. 30th, look and play are bar none. Could be best one yet, it's fire. Can't wait !

 
I agree, Madden looks sick. I like college alot more than the NFL and I keep giving the NCAA Football series another chance just to be disappointed. But Madden is by far the better series than NCAA Football.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Agree, I'm college thru and thru but when it comes to video game football I'm all about the best and in this case it's obvious.

 
Started a franchise with the 9ers on skill level All Pro, no adjustment to sliders, let me say it's been rough. This game is hard, last year I did the same on Madden level and had no troubles. Love the new difficulty and challenge.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Landlord of Memorial Stadium said:
Husker Richard said:
Blaze1up said:
Agree, I'm college thru and thru but when it comes to video game football I'm all about the best and in this case it's obvious.
Click to expand...

It's really frustrating that EA doesn't just use the same model for NCAA and Madden (same game just with college vs. NFL teams, maybe some minor gameplay tweaks). Like you said, it's obvious that Madden is superior and that is the case every year. I doubt fans of either series would complain if they were extremely similar. EA needs to bring NCAA up to Madden's level.
Click to expand...

Last year NCAA was on a higher level, as it also was from '07-'09 (which isn't saying much).
Click to expand...
The last Madden game I bought was in '07, so I don't have a lot of experience. However, I would say that Madden '07 was leagues better than NCAA '07. NCAA '07 was one of the worst football games I've ever played.

 
Back
Top