I still say if Adrian Martinez had executed the exact same plays against Iowa, we'd have called it a typical Adrian Martinez game. Good and bad.
Point being, I don't think Adrian Martinez coming back for a fifth season would have significantly improved our chances over starting Logan Smothers, who presumably will improve over his first start as a freshman.
I think a lot of people batter their eyes at the Iowa game.
But remember how perfectly the table had been set? Adrian Martinez sets the career total yardage record the game before, then steps aside for Logan Smothers for the season finale. Smothers puts together a potent mix of running and passing as Nebraska goes up 21 - 6 against the hated (and ranked) Iowa Hawkeyes and their supposedly top shelf defense as Memorial Stadium goes wild, basking in the hope that had been missing all season.
Then about 5 minutes of awfulness that infected offense, defense, and special team, as it has for most of the Scott Frost era.
Imagine no blocked punt. Nebraska holds on for a narrow win. It's a different mood around this place, even with a 4-8 season.