You're too late to this party. I fixed it years ago:
- Eight team playoff
- Five Power 5 Conference Champions (provided they are in the Top 12 of the final standings)
- Highest-rated Group of Five Champion auto-qualifies if they are in the Top 12
- Remaining teams chosen by committee
- No more than two per conference
Now that the field is set, how does the playoff itself actually work and how does it mesh with the other bowls?
- Those eight teams are locked into New Year's Six bowls on a rotating basis (as they do now with four)
- Remaining bowl assignments can proceed as they currently do
- Higher-seeded teams host the quarter final game two weeks after CCG weekend
- The four teams that lose in the quarter finals will be matched up in two pre-determined New Year's Six bowl games (rotating)
- The four teams that win in the quarter finals will move on to two other New Year's Six games as the semi-finals (rotating, as they do now)
- Championship game one week later (as it is now)
Bowl structure preserved. Conference championships matter. Group of Five teams have a chance. Doesn't extend the season (time-wise). Bowl season begins and ends with a bang.
QED
If it goes to 16 teams, it should be a Pod system
- Four 4-team Pods
- Play your Pod every year (those three teams home-and-home every two years)
- Play one other Pod every year (every other team every three years, home-and-home every six years)
- "Protected" games each year to preserve rivalries while balancing pods
- The team with the best record within each year's paired Pods goes to the CCG
At first I wanted to play half of a third Pod each year instead of the protected games (so you would play every team at least every-other year) but I think it would be too hard to keep all the rivalries so there would be too much push-back. I'd have to dig a little deeper to see if you could get that to work within the Pods.
East Pod: Ohio State, Penn State, Rutgers, Maryland
North Pod: Michigan, Michigan State, Minnesota, Northwestern
West Pod: Nebraska, Wisconsin, Iowa, Illinois
South Pod: Texas, Oklahoma, Purdue, Indiana
Protected - Scheduled in years where the Pods weren't already playing each other (red=always, black=if possible, trophy game not preserved)
Illinois - Northwestern, Purdue, Ohio State
Indiana - Michigan State,
Iowa - Minnesota,
Maryland -
Michigan - Ohio State,
Michigan State - Indiana, Penn State, Rutgers
Minnesota - Iowa, Wisconsin, Penn State, Nebraska
Nebraska - Oklahoma, Minnesota
Northwestern - Illinois,
Ohio State - Michigan, Illinois
Oklahoma - Nebraska,
Penn State - Michigan State, Minnesota
Purdue - Illinois,
Rutgers - Michigan State
Texas -
Wisconsin - Minnesota,
Trophy Games not guaranteed - Illinois/Ohio State, Minnesota/Penn State, Nebraska/Minnesota, Michigan State/Rutgers
Actually, I do kind of like the look of that. Still has the issue of the Central pod looking week from a historical perspective. But if you the flipped Iowa into the Central and made a couple other swaps with the lower teams the pods line up pretty well geographically (only Northwestern is a bit out of place - you could flop Illinois and Northwestern without changing much and the geography would line up a little better but I like my way better), balanced pretty well historically and might be a little better on the rivalries.....
East Pod: Ohio State, Penn State, Rutgers, Maryland
North Pod: Michigan, Michigan State, Purdue, Indiana
Central Pod: Wisconsin, Iowa, Minnesota, Illinois
West Pod: Nebraska, Oklahoma, Northwestern, Kansas
Trophy Games - Green= in pod; Red=protected intra-pod (played every year), Black=if possible, trophy game not preserved)
Illinois - Northwestern, Ohio State, Purdue
Indiana - Michigan State, Purdue
Iowa - Minnesota, Wisconsin, Nebraska
Kansas -
Maryland - Penn State
Michigan - Michigan State, Ohio State, Minnesota
Michigan State - Michigan, Indiana, Penn State
Minnesota - Iowa, Wisconsin, Michigan, Penn State, Nebraska
Nebraska - Iowa, Wisconsin, Minnesota
Northwestern - Illinois
Ohio State - Penn State, Michigan, Illinois
Oklahoma -
Penn State - Maryland, Ohio State, Michigan State, Michigan, Minnesota
Purdue - Indiana, Illinois
Rutgers -
Wisconsin - Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska
It's kind of a coin flip to protect Nebraska/Wisconsin or Nebraska/Minnesota. I went with Nebraska/Wisconsin for two reasons: it's the best way to even out the schedules (toughens Wisconsin's, less-brutal for Minnesota) and because I like that one better.
The only Trophy games not preserved yearly - they would still be played every three years - are Minnesota/Penn State (Governor's Vicotry Bell - only started when Penn St joined the B1G), Minnesota/Nebraska (fun but not nearly the historical significance of the others) and Illinois/Purdue (Purdue Cannon..... eh).
Word is the athletic department is working on two major scenarios: 33% capacity and 50% capacity. Or 100% but they already know how to do that.
I thought these were some interesting numbers - the breakdown of how the total seats are currently allocated:
General public season tickets: about 66,220 (roughly 76%)
Faculty/Staff tickets: 7,052 (8.23%)
Student tickets: 6,983 (8.12%)
Visiting team: 3,000 (3.51%)
Suite tickets: 2,528 (2.94%)
Band section: 516 (0.62%)