Because no one can win the Orange Bowl, set the Orange Bowl rushing record (this bowl has been around awhile), win 11 games in a season, and beat the 7th ranked team with the option. Oh wait, they just did. Not only did they win, the game was over by the start of the 4th quarter. What I wouldn't give to see a fullback with an N on his helmet running over defenders again, just like the Yellowjackets did to the helpless Bulldogs all game long.
Don't get me wrong. I want Riley's pro-style Coryell/Imani and Newby up the middle play-action/hit the TE, find a receiver offense to work as much as any other Husker fan. We've just been there, done that for 10 years, and looking into my crystal ball, I see 3 and out after 3 and out.
In one season. People forget a lot of things in regardds to an exlusive option attack in college football. This years Ga Tech team was veteran, It had been a few years in the building. Are Husker fans willing to put up with 7-6's, 8-5's for that chance at a conference title game and 11 wins every 3-5 years when the stars align? Also, talent wins games. How many of them Ga Tech offensive players will be in the NFL.
Solich over-utilized and over-relied on the option game. It's pretty much was ruined him. And folks forget that the TO 90's teams didnt run the option 40 times a game. It was no less a utility play than it under Beck. If you wanna get the talent needed to be elite in college, you have to offer a system that will best prepare the players for the NFL.
After ELEVEN years, are we still seriously deluded enough to think the next Stafford, Winston, McCarron, Bortles, etc is gonna land in Lincoln? It just ain't gonna happen. And if you can't get one of those guys to run a pro-style offense, it won't do very well. We CAN, however, attract real talent at the O-line, RB, and TE, just like we used to. I like the WR's we have now, and those that have graduated, but who among them is doing much in the NFL? Helu is doing well, as is Niles, but at TE. Burkhead finally got some touches, but we haven't seen him in the game much. Who else offensively is doing much in the no fun league?
Also, we haven't had an eleven-win season since 2001. When we ran option. And, just because we're running option, why does that mean we would have the same record as GT has? Running it successfully would absolutely help all the talent we get on defense - much more than GT is able to get.
Both GT and UNL have issues with recruiting. We know the problems we face. GT has high admission standards, and has trouble pulling blue chips vs other teams in the area. They were picked to finish sixth in their DIVISION before the season, and took FSU to the wire in the championship game, beat Georgia, and literally pounded MSU in the Orange bowl. Remember that bowl - the one we used to got to all the time - when we ran option? They aren't loaded with 4 and 5 stars on either side of the ball, yet beat teams that finish with higher recruiting ratings than them every season.
I like the option look, be it out of the I, flexbone, or splitbacks (never the wishbone, on principle), because you take all the pressure, and evenly divide it among 4 guys in the backfield, and ultimately on the o-line, and receivers stalk-blocking downfield. In the pro-set, a disproportionate amount of pressure is on the QB to not only read a defense, but make pro-level throws while avoiding pocket pressure. There aren't many guys that really handle that well. It's hard to blitz an option offense, but it is very effective against a pro-style offense, as we found out in '04 and '05. Zac Taylor took more and harder hits from blitzers than I ever saw any option qb take before him.
Finally, there's the preparation aspect. Even today, as was the reality in the past - when every team we play only sees our style once a season, it's hard to be fully prepared for it - one of the main reasons Osborne switched in '80 was because OU had so much success with it, and it was hard to be ready for. We aren't going to get elite, pro-level prospects in the numbers we need. We HAVE to be different, if we are going to have an edge. As I see it, pro-style more of the same, and everyone we play will be ready for it.