What has Mickey pulled off that was amazing? I like the hire, don't get me wrong, but is pulling high rated guys out of the school's own backyard anything special really? According to this, just 1 of his top 15 all time recruits were from outside Louisiana and that was one state over.Another thing about Brennan is that I think he wants to stay someplace close enough to home to where his family can watch him play. I know Tulane was mentioned as another possible landing spot when he first entered the portal. But hey, I've seen Mickey Joseph pull off some amazing things during his time at LSU, so nothing is out of the realm of possibility.
If SF strikes out with all of these qbs, he may consider re-recruiting AM. I am being sarcastic, but he may wind up with no one better in all reality.
An upgrade over Martinez will be in decision making and turnovers.I'd put the odds of us finding an actual upgrade over Martinez in the portal at pretty much zilch. More likely, it would be someone not necessarily better or worse, just a different style of QB.
What I worry is that they'll try and bring in a pocket passer, who will get creamed because he can't scramble like Martinez when our awful line breaks down...
I think some of the changes might be a little too late. BUT, hoping with a HUGE upgrade in experience in some key positions (still holding out hope on RB/ST) that they can use/develop what we have and get the improvement needed.An upgrade over Martinez will be in decision making and turnovers.
With Michigan in the playoffs, it magnifies Martinez fumble in that game
....and 4 INTs in a game simply cannot happen.
I'm excited about Whipple's experience versus Verduzco's.
If nothing else we saw that Smothers was pretty decent. Had he won against Iowa I guarantee people would be wanting him next year. The play that actually lost us that game was the punt. If we retain Smothers that's not the end of the world. The problem with that senario is that Smothers is more of an option QB. Not sure that fits with what the new OC wants to do. Although the OC may just have to adjust. I like what they were doing offensively against Iowa and I would love to continue doing that. In case of injury we need to at least get someone who can back up Smothers if we can find someone that can beat him out, but can our new OC run that kind of offense?I'd put the odds of us finding an actual upgrade over Martinez in the portal at pretty much zilch. More likely, it would be someone not necessarily better or worse, just a different style of QB.
What I worry is that they'll try and bring in a pocket passer, who will get creamed because he can't scramble like Martinez when our awful line breaks down...
Whether Smothers can consistently throw the long ball remains to be seen, but his accuracy and decision-making looked pretty good to me.If nothing else we saw that Smothers was pretty decent. Had he won against Iowa I guarantee people would be wanting him next year. The play that actually lost us that game was the punt. If we retain Smothers that's not the end of the world. The problem with that senario is that Smothers is more of an option QB. Not sure that fits with what the new OC wants to do. Although the OC may just have to adjust. I like what they were doing offensively against Iowa and I would love to continue doing that. In case of injury we need to at least get someone who can back up Smothers if we can find someone that can beat him out, but can our new OC run that kind of offense?
Well......the Michigan team we lost to by 3 is a playoff team and Harbaugh has been named coach of the year in college football.I think some of the changes might be a little too late. BUT, hoping with a HUGE upgrade in experience in some key positions (still holding out hope on RB/ST) that they can use/develop what we have and get the improvement needed.
What has Mickey pulled off that was amazing? I like the hire, don't get me wrong, but is pulling high rated guys out of the school's own backyard anything special really? According to this, just 1 of his top 15 all time recruits were from outside Louisiana and that was one state over.
https://247sports.com/Coach/Mickey-Joseph-3745/AllTimeRecruits/
I don’t think it’s putting all your eggs in one basket to try to bring in a QB who has a history of performing better than anyone currently on the roster. Competition is a good thing and we can’t avoid it over the prospect of a QB possibly transferring out. It is a make or break year for Frost. 2AM was definitely better than Smothers yet he couldn’t do better than 3-9. I don’t think much of that dismal record was 2AMs fault but still you improve the position if you can.Whether Smothers can consistently throw the long ball remains to be seen, but his accuracy and decision-making looked pretty good to me.
It’s not his fault we fair catch at the six like halfwits then call passes out of the end zone. I bet Mr. Whipple doesn’t do stupid things like that.
I’m okay continuing with him if there’s not a better option. Let’s not put all our eggs in the basket of a portal guy who might slip on the ice walking across campus.
I'm not sure I am following. Michigan brought in a new DC, DB coach, safeties coach, RB coach, QB coach and reassigned OL coach... He was 2-4 last year, but had all winning seasons we'd die for previously.....Harbaugh, to date has coached circles around Frost. Beat him while at UCF and here. I'm tired of pointing to one score losses to how show close we are. We suck. Plain and simple. You don't go 3-9 and and not be able to win half of those 1 score games and think we are close. We have a 4 year record of this. And now the NCAA record for one score losses in a single season. One I am confident we will hold for ever....Harbaugh made changes after 1 year. It took Frost 4. So do I expect Frost to make this turn around? No. Do I think Frost has the coaching acumen of Harbaugh? No. And again, to point out a loss to show we are better is mind boggling. Is that how far we have fallen? We point to one score losses as some victory. King of the losers? Again, maybe I am missing the point.Well......the Michigan team we lost to by 3 is a playoff team and Harbaugh has been named coach of the year in college football.
How many new assistants did they have this season?
But Frost passed on Burrows he would have been an AA here....Frost was an idiot. JKI don’t think it’s putting all your eggs in one basket to try to bring in a QB who has a history of performing better than anyone currently on the roster. Competition is a good thing and we can’t avoid it over the prospect of a QB possibly transferring out. It is a make or break year for Frost. 2AM was definitely better than Smothers yet he couldn’t do better than 3-9. I don’t think much of that dismal record was 2AMs fault but still you improve the position if you can.
If our OL and STs don’t improve it wouldn’t matter if we had Joe Burrow or CJ Stroud back there.
The point is the assistant coaching changes helped take Michigan to the next level.I'm not sure I am following. Michigan brought in a new DC, DB coach, safeties coach, RB coach, QB coach and reassigned OL coach... He was 2-4 last year, but had all winning seasons we'd die for previously.....Harbaugh, to date has coached circles around Frost. Beat him while at UCF and here. I'm tired of pointing to one score losses to how show close we are. We suck. Plain and simple. You don't go 3-9 and and not be able to win half of those 1 score games and think we are close. We have a 4 year record of this. And now the NCAA record for one score losses in a single season. One I am confident we will hold for ever....Harbaugh made changes after 1 year. It took Frost 4. So do I expect Frost to make this turn around? No. Do I think Frost has the coaching acumen of Harbaugh? No. And again, to point out a loss to show we are better is mind boggling. Is that how far we have fallen? We point to one score losses as some victory. King of the losers? Again, maybe I am missing the point.
The punt plus the safety were killers for us. And in my opinion Smothers was set up to fail in the play that was called. Smothers looks like he could manage a game well if given a chance.If nothing else we saw that Smothers was pretty decent. Had he won against Iowa I guarantee people would be wanting him next year. The play that actually lost us that game was the punt. If we retain Smothers that's not the end of the world. The problem with that senario is that Smothers is more of an option QB. Not sure that fits with what the new OC wants to do. Although the OC may just have to adjust. I like what they were doing offensively against Iowa and I would love to continue doing that. In case of injury we need to at least get someone who can back up Smothers if we can find someone that can beat him out, but can our new OC run that kind of offense?