QB Luke McCaffrey [Nebraska - Signed LOI]

To Which School Will McCaffrey Commit?

  • Total voters
    38
Cdog923 said:
I'm of the mind that if we're going to have him at QB, he needs to be at QB exclusively. 
Click to expand...
I agree. I think we are bringing in enough athletes and we need to build solid depth behind Martinez. It would benefit McCaffrey the most if his time was focused on being trained as a QB. As well as benefit Nebraska so if in the future Martinez would get hurt- we could have some solid depth.

 
I am sure McCaffrey will have the bulk of his training and development at QB.  However, if he's talented and athletic enough to make a difference on the field, I don't see anything wrong with getting him on the field in another position.  As long as he doesn't get hurt, I don't see how it would harm his development at QB.  McCaffrey also may be the type of guy who wants to get on the field and help the team.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
ColoradoHusk said:
I am sure McCaffrey will have the bulk of his training and development at QB.  However, if he's talented and athletic enough to make a difference on the field, I don't see anything wrong with getting him on the field in another position.  As long as he doesn't get hurt, I don't see how it would harm his development at QB.  McCaffrey also may be the type of guy who wants to get on the field and help the team.
Click to expand...


Practice reps, mainly. Working at other positions takes away from his development at the QB position, both in terms of basic development and development within the offense. 

 
Cdog923 said:
Practice reps, mainly. Working at other positions takes away from his development at the QB position, both in terms of basic development and development within the offense. 
Click to expand...
He can get his allotted reps at QB, but also work in at WR for a package of plays each week.  I am not saying to put him solely at WR, but backup QB's, especially #3 and #4 aren't getting a ton of reps during practice once the season starts.  Plus, getting reps at WR could benefit him learning the offense, as he will see the offense from a different point of view.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
ColoradoHusk said:
He can get his allotted reps at QB, but also work in at WR for a package of plays each week.  I am not saying to put him solely at WR, but backup QB's, especially #3 and #4 aren't getting a ton of reps during practice once the season starts.  Plus, getting reps at WR could benefit him learning the offense, as he will see the offense from a different point of view.
Click to expand...


I agree with this, this is all so 'hypothetical Tuesday', but if he's a good enough athlete to contribute as a WR and isn't the starting QB they should get him on the field.  Ryan Tannehill showed it can work.

 
FrankWheeler said:
I agree with this, this is all so 'hypothetical Tuesday', but if he's a good enough athlete to contribute as a WR and isn't the starting QB they should get him on the field.  Ryan Tannehill showed it can work.
Click to expand...
The basic question is would you rather have McCaffrey running the scout team offense as QB in 2019, or would you rather have him getting 10-15 snaps a game at WR?  I know my answer.

 
ColoradoHusk said:
The basic question is would you rather have McCaffrey running the scout team offense as QB in 2019, or would you rather have him getting 10-15 snaps a game at WR?  I know my answer.
Click to expand...


That depends on where he is on the depth chart.  If he can beat out Bunch fairly quickly, you'd have Martinez/Vedral/McCaffrey running our offense and Bunch/Masker running the scout teams.

I would be pretty surprised if McCaffrey gets moved right away.  We backed off recruiting some other guys so he would be our QB in this class.  He definitely needs some development as he hasn't played as much QB as a lot of guys when they come out of high school.  But that's kind of a perfect fit for us as we can afford to let him develop behind an established started.

I wouldn't think they'd look to move him at least until there is another QB who comes later and that guy beats him out.  If even then.

 
Mavric said:
That depends on where he is on the depth chart.  If he can beat out Bunch fairly quickly, you'd have Martinez/Vedral/McCaffrey running our offense and Bunch/Masker running the scout teams.

I would be pretty surprised if McCaffrey gets moved right away.  We backed off recruiting some other guys so he would be our QB in this class.  He definitely needs some development as he hasn't played as much QB as a lot of guys when they come out of high school.  But that's kind of a perfect fit for us as we can afford to let him develop behind an established started.

I wouldn't think they'd look to move him at least until there is another QB who comes later and that guy beats him out.  If even then.
Click to expand...
Fair enough, he may not be running the scout team, but even at 3rd string, McCaffrey wouldn't be getting a ton of reps at QB once the season starts.  I think it would be reasonable to get McCaffrey a package of plays he could run at WR.  Of course, that's dependent on all of the other talent at the WR position, but it's not a stretch that McCaffrey could see some time at WR.

 
ColoradoHusk said:
Fair enough, he may not be running the scout team, but even at 3rd string, McCaffrey wouldn't be getting a ton of reps at QB once the season starts.  I think it would be reasonable to get McCaffrey a package of plays he could run at WR.  Of course, that's dependent on all of the other talent at the WR position, but it's not a stretch that McCaffrey could see some time at WR.
Click to expand...


I know Frost's story was we were going to have multiple stations going so guys were getting lots of reps - a la Osborne back in the day.  I haven't really heard anything more about that lately but the media doesn't get to watch practice so it's tough to know.  

But for how much they talked about it I would think there would be at least two groups running.  So if they are rotating the 2nd & 3rd string QBs in that second group they should still be getting pretty decent reps.

 
I just hope they keep him in a position that he can actually play, because if they put him at something like Defensive Tackle, I bet he would suck at that.

 
Back
Top