This message is for the folks who are having a fit over star rankings and position rankings. No matter what position a recruit is ranked at, there is no guarantee they will succeed at the college level. Why? At the high school level if you are faster and more athletic than the players around you you can dominate without have any grasp of the offense that your team is running or no understanding of the defensive scheme your team is running. Thus, such a player can be rated a 4-star or 5-star but may lack the mental aspect of the game. There are recruits that fit into that description every single year. Some high school coaches will warn colleges about it and some will not (want to market their recruit numbers....like
some programs in Alabama).
Some players play well at a position and then move to a different position and play at a much higher level. Often times that recruit will go unnoticed among the college recruiters, but not the coaches. Why? The coaches will vote that player to an All-State team and the local media folks will vote them to the same team as well (with some variances).
Some recruits are not flashy but are solid football players and exceed at the next level. Some recruits are flashy but never see the field at the next level.
Some recruits DO fly under the radar. That is the reality of college football recruiting. When there are over 3,000 high school football players singing LOIs on February 6th, there will be some recruits who only had one offer that will end up a starter in the NFL. There will be recruits we watched at the All American games that never see the field.
In the state I live in, out of the top five recruits the state has produced over the last 10 years only one of them became a regular starter at the college level. Over the last 25 years the most successful player from our state that went onto the NFL was a guy that the head coach refused to take a look at even after every local high school coach told him to take a look at the player as he was legit. So this high school kid show sup at the campus and kept asking for a chance to show his speed to the college coach. Eventually the college coach gave in....many, many years later he started in the NFL as a safety for many seasons. Guess what happened to the last 5-star recruit my state produced? Didn't start until his 5th year in the program.
We all know recruiting is not an exact science. Not every recruit that is a legit player is going to have offers from all of the major local schools. Some times players fly under the radar and that is the reality of life. We found a player that flew under the radar and recruited him hard after the coaches evaluated the senior film. The success of such a recruit is up to the recruited player....continued development and work ethic.
Most people assume that Wisconsin is a big running team because they have such great offensive lineman and running backs. That is actually false. The real reason is the QB and WR recruiting has been so bad for a few seasons now.......you may have heard of "recruiting" graduated players from other programs to be the QB.