I honestly don't know the answer to this.
These military academies are so often at the top of the list in rushing and their coaches so often are listed by fans as someone who we need to hire because of it.
So.....who has been successful rushing the ball at these academies and has left to a P5 program and replicated that success into being a dominant winning program?
Unless I'm missing something, none of the top 5 in the playoff rankings are in the top 10 in rushing offenses.The closest one is Oregon and #17.Fair point and I honestly have not followed too many who left academies for P5. I do think it's still a pretty significant accomplishment to lead an offense that finished in the top 4 in rushing for so many consecutive seasons. Since Pelini left, Nebraska has struggled with running the ball with our RBs on a consistent basis and I think a dominant rushing game should be the identity of the offense in the future. An OC that knows how to utilize RBs in conjunction with the OL can bring that skillset to the Big Ten in my opinion.
That's the key here I think. We don't need to be a power rushing team solely, we simply need to be able to use the power run when we need it and on demand. As you said, we must be able to throw the ball to win this conference and make the playoff. If folks want to be Air Force and GT to only squeak out 6/7 wins some years and have losing seasons in others, that's what we'd get by switching solely to what they do. I personally still want hope of winning the conference again someday.Unless I'm missing something, none of the top 5 in the playoff rankings are in the top 10 in rushing offenses.The closest one is Oregon and #17.
https://www.ncaa.com/stats/football/fbs/current/team/23
Georgia = 41
Alabama = Not in top 50
Oregon = 17
OSU = 42
Nebraska = 33
Top 10 rushing offenses:
Airforce
Army
Syracuse
Arkansas
Ol Miss
Kent State
Michigan
Baylor
Coastal Carolina
Oregon State
Not really a hot list packed full of dominating teams.
You have to be able to both pass and run to be where we all want to be.
Like in the red zone and esp from the one yard line where we aren't in shotgun :facepalm:That's the key here I think. We don't need to be a power rushing team solely, we simply need to be able to use the power run when we need it and on demand.
Unless I'm missing something, none of the top 5 in the playoff rankings are in the top 10 in rushing offenses.The closest one is Oregon and #17.
https://www.ncaa.com/stats/football/fbs/current/team/23
Georgia = 41
Alabama = Not in top 50
Oregon = 17
OSU = 42
Cincinnati = Not in top 50
Nebraska = 33
Top 10 rushing offenses:
Airforce
Army
Syracuse
Arkansas
Ol Miss
Kent State
Michigan
Baylor
Coastal Carolina
Oregon State
Not really a hot list packed full of dominating teams.
You have to be able to both pass and run to be where we all want to be.
I am not saying we have to give up on a passing game to focus on a dominant running game. I feel a big part of our challenge in recent years has been our inability to get first downs on 3rd/4th and short or when we get in the red zone.
As for data, Michigan is not too far off making the playoff and they are in the top 10 this year. In 2019 Ohio State finished 3 in the final rankings and they were in the top 5 of rushing offenses in the nation.
Yes, we need to be better in those situations.I am not saying we have to give up on a passing game to focus on a dominant running game. I feel a big part of our challenge in recent years has been our inability to get first downs on 3rd/4th and short or when we get in the red zone.
As for data, Michigan is not too far off making the playoff and they are in the top 10 this year. In 2019 Ohio State finished 3 in the final rankings and they were in the top 5 of rushing offenses in the nation.
There is literally no proof that this is what would happen. I can throw out predictions, too: If we keep doing the crap we're doing now, we'll keep winning 3-5 games a season.That's the key here I think. We don't need to be a power rushing team solely, we simply need to be able to use the power run when we need it and on demand. As you said, we must be able to throw the ball to win this conference and make the playoff. If folks want to be Air Force and GT to only squeak out 6/7 wins some years and have losing seasons in others, that's what we'd get by switching solely to what they do. I personally still want hope of winning the conference again someday.
There is literally no proof that this is what would happen. I can throw out predictions, too: If we keep doing the crap we're doing now, we'll keep winning 3-5 games a season.
You are essentially making yourself one dimensional by doing that, teams will dare you to beat them throwing the ball and loading the box. This has played out in thousands of games, that is the proof you are ignoring. That is the goal of a defense to make an offense one dimensional and therefore easier to defend. You are helping them do that with this change.There is literally no proof that this is what would happen. I can throw out predictions, too: If we keep doing the crap we're doing now, we'll keep winning 3-5 games a season.