Well, broke down and bought a 360, skyrim, and a new tv. Liking the game enough to cause my longest break from the board in years. And if I keep this up, its only a matter of time til the wife hides the disk...
As for the game, agreed with the dislike of attribute removal.
Also wish they had scaled the magic system with the character leveling. A few of those spells are pretty fun to use, but completely useless at higher levels. Need some of the old spells back too. Where are you open lock!!!!????
Otherwise, I'm having a pretty damn good time collecting loot, abusing the crafting/enchanting system, and just plain old exploring. And maybe I'm old school and less impressed (or unimpressed?) by graphics, but I think the environments are beautiful. More than once I've rounded a corner and literally stopped to just take in the scenery on the screen.