The complaints have been that every thread turns into the same thing.
There are plenty of places to argue about the talent on the roster and how it's being used. A thread congratulating the players that made all-conference teams doesn't need to be another one.
Then why not address all the other threads that devolve into the same arguments? Only threads "congratulating" player accomplishments are subject to having tangent posts removed?
It's nothing personal against you, Mav. I hope you know that. I'm just curious about the enforcement/application here.
No, I know exactly what you're saying. You don't know how many times over the last 3-4 months I've said "I'm really going to look for derailing/off topic posts and try to redirect them."
The problem is, when the results are as bad as they've been this year, the bad stuff is 99% of what people talk about. It's almost impossible - for me at least - to pick out a thread and say "anyone trying to bring negativity into this thread is just trolling." The All-Conference thread was one place where that was obvious.
Look at the threads that have been posted to today. There's a tread about a
bowl game, another
bowl thread, a
Banker thread, a
TA thread, a
Callahan thread, a
thread about a different coach people wanted instead of Riley, a
thread about Accountability, a thread
about a future QB, a
thread about the coaches' bowl bonuses, another
thread about a preferred coach, and
another TA thread. Which of those threads can you really say it's out of place for someone to bring up something that didn't go very well this year? Same deal - I'm not trying to be a jerk to you, it's just really hard to say "you shouldn't be posting that here" in most of those threads.
There are a few "other" threads today -
Vote 4 Ameer, a
couple All-B1G threads, a
LB thread, the
Restaurant thread and a
Piesman thread. Other than people talking about tipping at restaurants, those threads have a combined 47 replies and most of those are in the All-B1G thread where I moved the above posts from.
It's frustrating to me because I understand people who say "people are just being negative in every thread." I'd really like to be able to do something about it. The problem is the negative things are what people like to argue about and there's plenty of that to go around right now.
If I had more time to really sift through all the treads, I'm sure there are posts that could be moved. But for the most part, the line is so grey and, honestly, things start to blur together.
If anyone has a solution, I'd love to hear it. If there are off-topic posts, I guess you could reply saying you think it's off topic and a Mod could pick it up but that's going to be a lot of arguing about whether it actually is or not.
I just don't know what the solution is - other than the Huskers playing better.