JJ Husker
Donor
You're missing my point (and I might be missing yours). I'm not saying THIS IS the one true God. I'm not saying any version IS the one true God. What I'm saying is I believe there is only one true God. I'm not claiming the Christian God or any other interpretation is correct. I think you're a little too hung up all these pssibilities and the thought that if so many are apparently wrong then they all must be wrong.But mine is the only logical approach to come at it from.Knapp, the problem with that approach is that you are allowing for there being multiple or different gods based on how people have chosen to describe him. When you approach it from there being only one true God who created everything, you can more easily see that all those different names and multiple versions are simply human beings attempts at describing the same, one thing.
I don't happen to believe that what I believe in is absolutely correct or the only way. And, I don't believe that those who believe differently are inherently wrong. But the one thing that I know, from deep in my being, is that there is one God, one creator. My Catholic Christian faith may very well not have him nailed down (no pun intended) perfectly. I realize my more specific beliefs are the result of where and when I was born and where and how I was raised. That does not force me (unlike you) to demand that one way has to be right and all others wrong. I think that one all-powerful creator would be more than capable of dealing with an infinite number of people's versions of him. So, my and other Christians way to salvation may be the belief that Jesus Christ died for us and our religions may say that is the only way. Personally, I think there may be other ways, especially for people who have never been exposed to that knowledge. I sure am not going solely rely on my lowly human brain to limit the possibilities of an all powerful omniscient being. Maybe all we can do is the best we can do and that would allow for the Christian way being correct for Christians and the Hindu way being correct for Hindus, etc. What if they're all right?
If you were born in Saudi Arabia, you'd be Muslim.
The approach that "this IS the one true god" rests SOLELY on where you were born. That's no basis for a faith so profound.
You can say you believe that God would be OK with people having an infinite number of versions of him. But Zeus is a disparate and distinct god from God, as is Jupiter, Odin, Zoroaster, etc. These are NOT versions of your god, they are wholly distinct. And they were in competition with your god, and your god SPECIFICALLY SAID that he is the "One true god." He only gave you ten rules, and this is one of them!
I do agree on this, though: "...all those different names and multiple versions are simply human beings attempts at describing the same, one thing."
They ARE trying to describe one thing, but it's not "god," it's Something We Don't Understand. That's where religion came from - a lack of understanding. We don't know what lightning is, what earthquakes are, what the sun is, so we make up a god to explain it. Over time, different groups of people met, they had different gods, so competition arose, "My god is greater than your god." You actually see this in the Bible, with the story of Elijah vs. the prophets of Baal. If Baal worshipers existed today, Baal would have been the one to send the lightning bolt down on the altar to consume the sacrifice, not Yahweh. History is written by the victors, so Elijah's story is told as truth.
People don't like things they can't explain. Ancient man explained these things with "god." That doesn't make them right, it shows they didn't understand things.
I'm not using God as an excuse for things I don't know the answer to. But I would say that maybe there are things we cannot know and things that exist and happen outside the reality our human brains can process. I would say that science is not the be all, end all that so many want to treat it like. If you can't imagine a supernatural, higher power that may have been responsible for creation, without limiting him to preconceived human understandings of "gods", we'll probably just have to let this go. You're hung up on specific renditions of a god and I'm simply stating I believe there is only one true God and maybe no religion, no person has completely or properly explained him yet. And it's possible we never will. I think science and my beliefs are perfectly compatible but I don't think science or mere human beings are capable of full and complete understanding of such an entity.