I admit, I cherry picked stats to prove a point, the same as you. I counted 4 games, not 3.I'm not cherry-picking statistics. I'm comparing how both teams did for the year. You're the one cherry-picking three games. It's tough to get your defense back when you're talking about the last three games he coached.You can cherry pick statistics to prove any point.I'm sure you would disagree. But the facts would make you wrong.I would disagree with that, we had a couple of bad games on defense but Cosgrove's defense completely melted down for 2/3 of a season.Last year's defense was basically the same as Cosgrove's last defense.I don't know if he'd be a good DC. But he's a really good recruiter. And he can't be any worse than the DC we have now.I don't agree with firing anybody else at this point - but please tell me why some of you think Bray is a shoe in for DC or would be good at it? No experience right?
Cosgrove.
You don't finish #122 in passing defense (in 2015) without melting down a significant amount of time. Especially playing against several not-that-great passing offenses.
In 2007, we allowed our opponents to gain 0.47 more yards per play against us than they did against the rest of their opponents that year.
In 2015, we allowed our opponents to gain 0.42 more yards per play.
So the 2015 defense was a little less than two inches per play better than the 2007 defense. So they were equally pathetic.
Put both defenses side by side and Cosgrove's was far worse. His defense quit on him at the Missouri game and in that game and the next 3 they gave up a combined 150 points and 2,161 yards of offense. Cosgrove never got his defense back either.
You only wish Banker was that bad.
In our last three losses, we've given up 140 points and 1,519 yards. And that's this year. So there isn't much difference between them. Other than Cosgrose's must have been somewhat better for part of the year to be that bad over those three games and still only be comparable to Banker's for the entire year.
That said, I chose those 4 games because Missouri is where the wheels came off and the next 3 games is the wagon entering a terminal skid, on it's side, with tongue and axels bent and twisted. Players quit on Cosgrove. Who has quit on Banker?
There is just no way that Banker, no matter how much you hate him, is as bad as Cosgrove was. Cosgrove's defense was so bad he got death threats on him and his family.
*Edit* Here's another point I just thought of. Is it fair to compare Banker's first year to Cosgrove's 4th? Cosgrove had 4 years to get those guys playing his defense properly. Last year was Banker's first at NU. I expect growing pains during a coaches first year.
Last edited by a moderator: